"is an Audacity Project file. Use the 'File > Open' command

recorded a song yesterday , and saved it as a .aup, as you do. But when I went back to open it today, it kept saying the file “is an Audacity Project file. Use the ‘File > Open’ command to open Audacity Projects” with the window title of “Error Importing”. I did go to “file” and then “open” to access the file, but the same error message came up.

It is version 2.1.2 on windows 10. It opened and closed fine all last night and I have not moved or changed the files. I did switch my pc off last night, but the other song I recorded still opens fine and is the same type of file saved at the same time.

Bit annoying since took me 4 hours to record yesterday, is there anything I can do or is the file just corrupt?

thanks

The AUP is the Project Manager. It’s not the whole Project. This is a Project.

Open the AUP in a text editor instead of Audacity. Is it blank or does it contain trash? This is part of a simplified AUP file.

It should have semi-English words in it telling Audacity what to do with all that stuff in the _DATA folder.

http://manual.audacityteam.org/man/audacity_projects.html

If it’s blank, it’s possible you turned off the computer before Audacity had time to finish writing the AUP file.

http://manual.audacityteam.org/man/recovery.html

Koz

Manual Recovery (at the bottom of that page) only works with a mono, not stereo recording. So the performance may be gone. It’s not a bad idea to Export a WAV (Microsoft), 16-bit of important work in addition to the Project. That’s a standard sound file that should open up anywhere.

Koz

yes there was nothing in the notepad

but i swear i saved hours before i switched pc off

Not actually true if you have NTFS file system (almost certainly the case if the machine came with Windows 10) and you use xplorer2 Pro (free trial) to access the raw timestamps. See http://manual.audacityteam.org/man/recovering_crashes_manually.html#Automatic_recovery_tools.

Stereo recordings can’t be recovered with correct channel allocation on Mac or Linux (EXT3 file system) because the timestamp granularity is only one second.


Gale

hours before

We believe you. We’re getting more and more reports of Win10 “forgetting” to write the AUP file. It’s concerning.

Koz

http://manual.audacityteam.org/man/recovering_crashes_manually.html#Automatic_recovery_tools

Apparently, I copied out the wrong one. Are there more than two?

Koz

I remember this cycle. Mr. 404.
Screen Shot 2017-01-18 at 10.50.25 AM.png
Koz

I agree it’s a concern but is it really only Windows 10? I think we will have to track this as a “bug”, albeit not reproducible. The number of reports of empty saved AUP files went up as soon as we made the AUTOSAVE file a binary file rather than a human-readable XML file. It is a good bet there is a correlation.

On the other hand, the problems we used to have with the error where the AUTOSAVE file was not writable have disappeared completely as far as I know.

We went through this in a Private Message, Koz, if you recall. There are two pages.

Automatic Crash Recovery - Audacity Manual is the link for when Audacity crashes or has to be force quit with unsaved changes and so the Automatic Crash Recovery dialogue appears when you restart Audacity.

http://manual.audacityteam.org/man/recovering_crashes_manually.html is for when there is data but no usable AUP file that can be opened (or when Audacity has crashed/been force quit but there is no usable AUTOSAVE file from which Audacity can perform Automatic Crash Recovery).


Gale

if you recall.

Obviously not.

Koz

Does that qualify as “dark web?” Audacity documentation is cooler than I thought.

Koz

The number of reports of empty saved AUP files went up as soon as we made the AUTOSAVE file a binary file rather than a human-readable XML file. It is a good bet there is a correlation.

But we won’t have to worry about this in 2.1.4…

Koz

I think I can put money on it that you will, if you are suggesting 2.1.4 will have a single file project format.


Gale

Hahahaha - i’m putting money on that too :sunglasses: :ugeek:

if you are suggesting 2.1.4 will have a single file project format.

That’s what my ball said.


Of course, it’s not necessarily the final arbiter of technical prognostication, and further, it’s not even my ball. That’s my grandfather’s ball. I can’t find mine. It may be in a box in the garage [shudder]. I’m using the filial links extension and it seems to work OK.

But I do wish I could find mine. There’s just something about using a ball that could very well be older than I am. Creepy.

Koz

I know you’re saying to yourself, “Why don’t you use grampa’s ball to find yours?”

Grand idea.
MyBall-small.jpg
Koz