Silent Subliminals [solved?]

I would like to take this moment to say thank you. I’m not near to the conception of subliminaI messaging, but I needed something that wouldn’t cause a disturbance or distraction on my daily life. This script file has changed the game for me, and helped me get a better understanding to sound and how it works.

Since then, I have been able to successfully reprogram my subconscious mind with beliefs and ideas that i’ve always strived for. If it wasn’t for this, I would’ve had to continue playing my subliminaI recording with ambient sounds, but now I don’t have to anymore!

To anyone who reads this, it works 100%. I’m going to go in-depth with subliminaI messages and how they work.

• How do they work •

A subliminal recording plays affirmations at a frequency below the standard hearing threshold. They play at this frequency so the statements can bypass the logical and reasoning part of your mind.

Therefore, it doesn’t challenge or reject the affirmation you are trying to impress into the subconscious mind.

• You can’t hear it, so it doesn’t work! •

While you cannot hear the suggestions, the sound waves coming from the audio travel down the ear canal which send vibrations to your eardrums. Your subconscious mind is able to decipher these vibrations because these are the same vibrations that make up audible sounds.

It is also defined as the reception of the sound pressure waves and their perception or observation and interpretation by the brain.

See here: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5819010/

• Summary of the Subliminal audio •

Subliminal messages are like programs, and your mind executes these programs. In order for the programs to get downloaded, we need to use a subliminaI recording that contains the affirmations we’d like to install. Once the affirmations are downloaded, we have to install them.

How we do install the affirmations? Through repetition.

Imagine your mind is the PC, and your subliminaI affirmations as the installation process. Each time you play your subliminaI recording, the process of the installation increases. Whenever the subliminaI is playing, it keeps getting installed. One day, as you’ve been consistent with your subliminaI recording, the subliminaI affirmations will become fully installed into your subconscious mind, and be executed.

This is how our life works.

Anything that is consistently fed to the subconscious mind will one day become accepted and executed. So all you really need is a properly created subliminaI messaging track, and the discipline in staying patient and committed to the subliminaI recording.

Consistency pays off!

After listening to the subliminaI messaging track every day and night for 3 - 6 months, the subliminaI affirmations will become beliefs, which influences a shift in perception, thoughts, feelings, and behavior.

• Conclusion •
I’m going to leave it at this, but i’m forever grateful for this amazing stuff because it has changed my life around! Truly thank you again for getting this code, it made subliminaI programming so much fun, and it hasn’t caused any disturbance into my life. I have moments where I even forget the audio is playing, so whenever I experience a random shift in mindset is when I realized. These audio programs are very powerful and can help you break bad habits, and get rid of limiting-beliefs that you’ve picked up from the media or environment you grew up in. Do you know why habits are hard to break? It’s because we run on auto pilot by our day to day habits we have formed through repetition. And because our habits are stored in the subconscious part of our mind, that’s the place we have to work from to reprogram it. Ignoring these tools are a big mistake, because if used properly you can change your life around for the better. I know this because I changed mine in 6 months. I used to suffer from depression, anxiety, low self-esteem, lack of love for myself, and self-hatred. I still can’t believe I was able to change that around, but it worked, and that is why I’m here to show my appreciation! I’m so happy and hope many more give these tools a chance. I notice the site admin Steve believes it’s mumbo-jumbo, but I can promise you it isn’t, definitely give it a try!

1 Like

Hello ,
I’m bit confused because i am new to all this . Basically i want help that how can i create a silent subliminal like is it really helpful by using the code to switch the frequency to 17500 hz ?
Though i did all of this and all i could hear in my earphones was whistling sound so is it ok ? can it be understood by my mind ??
Or there is any other way to create a silent subliminal . If there is please let me know each and everything :slight_smile:

Personally I think that silent subliminals can’t be understood by the mind because at best the mind is only aware of the whistling. The idea that the mind can (a) perceive silent “sound”, and (b) demodulate that sound at the correct frequency to decode it, is preposterous. Others, like GlazerX (previous post) disagree. On the other hand, if you know that something you are listening to contains a beneficial message, then like the placebo effect, the time spent listening may well have a beneficial effect.

Actually, look into the work of David Eagleman at MIT, on sensory substitution. Our senses seem to be doing general pattern recognition. The type of data coming in on a sensory channel is essentially irrelevant. With enough time to practice (it’s not much, a few days, maybe a week), we can learn to accept visual data via sound, sound by touch etc. One classic example of a similar phenomenon, was an experiment involving subjects wearing glasses which inverted their vision, for a couple weeks. Eventually their brain learned and they interpreted the world normally, and could do everything they used to… it took about 2 weeks If I remember correctly… When taken off the world looked upside down to them. Scary… but relearning the old behavior didn’t take nearly as long apparently.

The high frequency carrier really isn’t that much different form us perceiving a binaural beat. why? because it’s still within the range of human hearing…the ear still responds, even if we don’t tend to perceive that range consciously. Even with the silent subliminals I have heard, turning it up to a higher volume **, causes a strange effect when your hearing feels muffled, even though you aren’t heading anything.


**Do NOT do this unless you know how to calibrate the ACTUAL volume at a safe level… these frequencies can damage your ears, even if you can’t hear them…and that again is a testament to the idea that we can hear them, just not perceive them… In this case, the actual volume level of the sound was at a level similar to music a bit above conversational level, but not damaging by any stretch.

Now as to subliminals not working on a particular person, of course they do, just not in your experiments. Context is everything. If you don’t want to follow the suggestion, or don’t believe it can work, then it is very unlikely to. While the silent sound process bypasses the critical faculty, because we can’t consciously perceive it, we aren’t alerted to respond emotionally to it… to get what I mean think…we aren’t ‘triggered by it’. even if we otherwise would be… but this isn’t all that is required… we also have pre programed responses or beliefs that might run contrary to the affirmation. In those cases it won’t work… additionally… think of the first… ‘drink cocoa cola’ subliminal experiments. seeing it subliminally is no different than hearing it in a regular old commercial or seeing it on a billboard. it won’t make you drink a coca cola… it won’t make you do anything at all . but if you are thirsty it might offer you a suggestion that seems like a good idea for you . if that is the case, the you might respond to it but not have any idea that you are doing so… but you would have anyway… You might think… what good is that ? well again… what if you want to make a change… like quit smoking…genuinely you want to… but you have beliefs which run counter to the idea that you have what it takes to quit… a subliminal is a good way to progressively shape your programmed beliefs on the matter, in the direction you want… but just like practicing ANYTHING, you need to do it enough to learn it… and you have to be amenable to that change… like you have to be thirst for coca cola, of in this case… eager to quit… and soon your beliefs will start to line up with your experience… which is that you want to quit… the actual real life thought, or amenability, is a necessary part that most people just don’t understand, it even know about. In hypnosis it would be like a convincer… an experience which removes doubt in the experience.

So when I say of course it’s working…I men’s the process works and you ARE responding to it… just maybe not achieving a particular result, if the criteria I mentioned are not met. if you think you are ugly… I can say you are beautiful 10,000 times and it won’t matter… see what I mean? But if you wanted to believe it, were ready to believe it…but just didn’t… then it might start to change your mind. If we didn’t respond to subliminal information we wouldn’t respond to most threats we experience while driving… like a cat jumping across the road out of nowhere… we don’t respond quickly enough consciously to respond to that… if we didn’t respond to subliminal information that mechanism woulnt work…

Dear Edgar, thank you for all your work! You wrote:

Could you please explain the difference exactly between the subliminal.ny and subliminal-rft.ny ? I assume that you asserts that subliminal.py is better than subliminal-rft.ny since you wrote the former after the later. But I have also seen subliminal-rft.ny with this additional code at the end:

(if (arrayp s)
(vector (modulator (aref s 0) f) (modulator (aref s 1) f))
(modulator s f))

What exactly does the additional code do and (to be absolutely certain what your opinion is) which of these three scripts are the best?

Edgar has not visited this forum since about 10 years ago, but from looking at the code, there’s not much difference.

The main difference is that if the track’s sample rate is less than 44100 Hz, then the error message from subliminal.ny is in German, whereas in subliminal-rft.ny it is in English.

The other difference is that subliminal.ny has a check that caps the selected carrier frequency to a maximum of 3kHz below the Nyquist frequency.
Example:
If the track’s sample rate is 44100Hz, then the Nyquist frequency is 22050 Hz. 3kHz below that is 22050 - 3000 = 19050 Hz. So if you set the carrier frequency to 20000 Hz, then the subliminal.ny plug-in would change the selected carrier frequency to 19050 Hz, whereas subliminal-rft.ny would use the selected carrier frequency of 20000 Hz.
If the track sample rate is 46000 Hz or higher, then the effects are identical.

It is recommended to use a sample rate of 48000 or 96000 Hz, in which case the effects will be identical.

Thank you very much Steve for your informative and kind response. :slight_smile: There is another interesting silent-subliminal code written for Pure Data. Perhaps you know enough about programming and coding to say anything about it. If would be interesting to compare it with the subliminal.ny. You can read about and download it here: http:_//_grh.mur.at/blog/silent-subliminals/

The programming looks similar, but the statement that the modulated signal “can be demodulated by the ear” seems highly improbable and without foundation in reality.

Yes “demoduated by the ear” is highly improbable. If ultrasonic subliminal works they probably work by some process similar to bone conduction for which there are some research. It has been shown that ultrasonic messages even at high frequencies can be “demodulated” by the brain if the producer of the ultrasound is connected directly to the skin.

Going back to the Pure Data script, do you know how to use the patch? It would be interesting to apply both scripts to the same affirmation and compare the result.

Another thing, assuming that ultrasonic messages possibly may work, would not the best frequency be as low as possible although high enough to be undetected, for three reasons:

(1) a carrier frequency at say 13000 Hz would be less likely to cause ear damage compare to say 17 000 Hz when used with higher db.
(2) The probability that it can be “demodulated” by the brain should be higher at a lower supersonic frequency than a higher one.
(3) The drawback with supersonic sound compare to ordinary or infrasound is that it has less reach, and thus a sound at 13000 Hz would have better range than at 17 000 Hz with the same db.
?

Just to let you know, I have a scientific / engineering background and it is my opinion that “Silent Subliminals” are pseudo-science nonsense. I fully appreciate that others have different opinions, which they are perfectly entitled to hold. My only interest in this subject is with regard to using Audacity software effectively. I’ve been involved with Audacity, as a user, developer and QA for well over a decade, and I’m happy to help other Audacity users, whatever their area of interest.

Sorry but I have only a passing knowledge of Pd. Their user portal is here: https://puredata.info/
I’m happy to answer any questions about the Nyquist code (as that’s an area that I know about :wink:)

No problem, I have serious doubts myself. When it comes to subliminals done the traditional way (i.e. “masked subliminals”) there exit a very large amounts of evidence (scientific studies in peer-review journals) that shows that it has effect. There is no consensus, however of the extent and exactly what areas it can affect. By contrast, there are no scientific study (so far I know) that shows that ultrasonic subliminals can be detected by the unconscious.

However, there are some indications/evidence that it could work. First that there are studies that shows that people can detect even very high frequency sound via the body, and also can decode ultrasonic messages if frequency inducing gadget is connected to the body (if I remember it correctly). That in in itself is fascinating but it does not prove that ultrasonic messages mediated by the air can be decoded.

Secondly, there is research that shows that the brain reacts to ultrasonic sound mediated by the air even though the brain is not consciously aware of it. This does not prove that subliminal messages delivered in this way would effect the brain, but it proves that the brain reacts to ultrasonic stimuli of which it is not consciously aware.

Thirdly, and this is most interesting, do you know about Silent Sound Spread Spectrum (SSSS sometimes called “S-quad” or “Squad”? This method were used by the USA in the war against Iraq (HEXEN2039). I was in contact with those researchers (including Edward Tilton) and I have several of their CDs including two custom made which I am the only in the world to possess (as far as I know) and the brain cluster inducement really works. It is incredible but I cannot deny that it works, and then I would suspect that the silent subliminals would work as well, (the USA defense should have scientific reason for implementing lowerys patent). Again this is no conclusive proof, but and indication at least, and together with the two other indications it is interestingly enough for me at least to pursue the subject.

I’m happy to answer any questions about the Nyquist code (as that’s an area that I know about > :wink:> )

That’s good enough! :slight_smile: Could you please explain this code that I have seen in some of subliminal.ny at the end of it:

(if (arrayp s)
(vector (modulator (aref s 0) f) (modulator (aref s 1) f))
(modulator s f))

What difference does this additional code do?

Nyquist sees a mono track as a “sound”. (In Nyquist, a “sound” is a data type, is the same way as numbers, character, lists, arrays… are data types)

Nyquist sees stereo tracks as an array of sounds, where the left track channel is the first element of the array, and the right channel is the second element of the array.

ARRAYP is a “predicate”, which in programming means that it tests something and returns True or False. In this case it tests whether something is an array.

In old plug-ins, “S” represents the selected track that is to be processed (in later plug-ins this was changed to TRACK)

So the first line looks to see if the selected track is an array (True for stereo tracks, False for mono tracks).

If the track is stereo, then it runs the code:

(vector (modulator (aref s 0) f)
        (modulator (aref s 1) f))

otherwise (the track is mono) it runs the code:

(modulator s f)

If the track is stereo, we want to process both channels and return a stereo sound back to Audacity. If it’s a mono track, then we just want to process the (one) sound and return the processed sound.

VECTOR is a quick way to create a one-dimensional array, which is exactly what we want for a stereo track.

AREF accesses an element in an array. In this case, (aref s 0) accesses the first element of “S” (the left track channel) and (aref s 1) accesses the second element (the right track channel).

MODULATOR is a function defined in the plug-in that modulates the sound with the carrier tone (frequency “F”), so

(vector (modulator (aref s 0) f)
        (modulator (aref s 1) f))

modulates the left and right channels of the selected (stereo) track and returns a stereo sound,
whereas

(modulator s f)

modulates the sound from a mono track and returns a mono sound.

Audacity replaces the selected sound with the “returned” sound (mono or stereo) from Nyquist.

Wow that was pedagogic and solid explanation! :smiley: I have some (exceedingly little) knowledge in the programming language of R, which uses the same concepts so this was very clarifying.

I have another interesting question. What can one say about the modified pattern of sound in audacity? A company Indigo Mind Labs sells commercial ultrasound subliminals, but it seems obvious that they use another kind of script if you compare their pattern to the one made by subliminal.py. If you look at the attached image the above is the commercial one and the beneath is the one modified by subliminal.py. Can one say anything based on the differences ?
Screenshot from 2022-06-14 13-07-16.png

So basically Silent Subliminals don’t work? what about Subliminal with beat tone? do they they work?

thank you for the brief ,though i still have a querie ,which is *does speeding up affirmations and not adding any music with making it unmasked work? “like a silent subliminal which is unmasked”

I have a question too, why use the subliminal plugin producing an SSB modulated carrier made by edgar when I can just use amplify to lower the db of the subliminal messages audio until I can’t hear it?

I assume some people believe that some methods work better than others.

IMO - If you can’t hear it they are all equally ineffective. :stuck_out_tongue:

That would be strange, cause all subs in youtube are silent

What is the logic behind this, after running a word or phrase through this script, what characteristics of the original spoken word or phrase are retained which might make it work?

Does the output retain some of the pattern of compression and rarefaction of the original word or phrase, which might be processed by the mind and understood but the conscious mind doesn’t here?

Thank you all. This has made me realize the Audacity forums is THE place to ask my technical inquiries.
Supposedly, a device transmits the audios directly into long-term memory in CNS, which can be lucrative…
As a result of the possibility to “download” knowledge into memories, much like in this clip from ‘The Matrix’;
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OrzgxUhnYjY
i have been wondering about the limits of how this could be done. The device i’m referring to is called a ‘Neurophone’

i need to know, under the additional condition, that the brain & CNS ARE able to interpret, separate, collate
and process info sent to it, when the signals get there “cleanly”, no matter the amount perceptible noise (or respective lack-of).
i want to play maybe 50 or 500 audiobooks simultaneously…maybe faster, too. what are the REAL limits
stopping this, besides the ability to consciously discern between various sources at the same time?

[link deleted]
Reading about the raw data processing speed of the human body here made me believe it could be so.
If anyone has comments on fitting as much sound into a std. 3.5mm audio cable, please let me know.
Do i just cram it in there, or only a few, and hope for the best (as long as i don’t have to listen anyway).
The plugin i will certainly try to implement into everything i listen to this way anyway,
It’s carrier is 37.5kHz and one (with electrodes) can hear audio in the middle of their head, naturally, with ears plugged u

Hope this is a good introduction, and many thanks…
kristjan.