Muffled Recording with Maya 44 USB Ex Soundcard

Hey all,
This is my first post on this forum. I am trying to record live mixing through a maya 44 soundcard. The input to the maya comes from my mixer, which has it’s own soundcard I use when mixing. When I record the mix on audacity, it comes through muffled. I’m sure this is an easy fix, but haven’t found any yet. Any help or ideas? Thanks much! I have the latest version of audacity, on windows 8.

Maya 44 USB Ex Soundcard

Audacity doesn’t use ASIO software, so whatever you think you’re recording, it’s probably not the full quality Maya.