Error Opening Recording Device.

Audacity 2.3.0 / Windows 10

I’m trying to use the windows WASAPI loopback. I’m using a Yeti Nano with 7.1 channel headphones.

When I recorded the first 3 times, it worked fine. When I tried to do it a 4th time, it gave me error code -9996 invalid device.

When monitoring the audio, it shows fine, it only gives the error when I hit record. Here are the settings I’m using: