Audacity Producing Hiss

Audacity will play a recording made with Audio Hijack perfectly, but when I try to split the file into separate tracks, they emerge with serious hiss.

I have tried splitting with cut and paste and with labels.

Audacity has been reinstalled.

I have downloaded OceanAudio and managed to split my file but OA is a lot more difficult to use.

Weird!

What is the format and are you saving to the same format?

And that’s the only thing you are doing? Splitting with no adjustments or effects?

The only things I can think of are… if you export as 8-bits you’ll get quantization noise which is like a ā€œfuzzā€ on top the audio.

Or dither which is intentional noise that’s supposed to sound better than quantization noise.

You shouldn’t hear either one at 16-bits or better.

Quantization goes-away with pure-digital silence whereas dither is constant.

Thank you for taking the trouble to reply.

The technical stuff is beyond me. I use Audacity on default settings. The only effect I use is fade out but didn’t do so in this case. The music is a symphony which I wanted to divide into movements.

I used AIFF on a Mac. I record on Audio Highjack and drag the file to Audacity which I use to ā€˜top and tail’ and to divide into tracks ready to burn a cd. I have been doing this for years with no problems.

Presumably my success with other software indicates that the fault must be with Audacity.

Still, VERY unusual… AIFF at 16-bits or better should be OK. And without dither the audio data shouldn’t be getting changed at all (except for the parts cut-out). But like I said, you can’t normally hear dither either…

and to divide into tracks ready to burn a cd.

This probably isn’t necessary with most classical music as long as there are gaps/silence between movements, but there is a way with a cue sheet to burn a CD from ā€œone big fileā€ and the cue sheet tells the burning software where to put the track markers. It works well with live rock concerts where there is continuous applause/audience noise between songs. I’ve used the same method with crossfaded mix CDs.

I’m on Windows and I don’t know what Mac burning software supports cue sheets. But you can make a cue sheet with a plain text editor. I usually start with a known good example and edit it.

Does this mean you have recorded a stream ie what was playing on your computer while it was playing? I know nothing about Mac software. If so, what site were you playing from?

It’s Ocenaudio. I use it for recording mainly because I find that part easier than Audacity. I do find Audacity ā€˜better’ for editing. How did you find out how to split files with Ocenaudio?
Are you willing to share your project file so I can try what you did and see what happens for me?
Mark B

Hello

Thank you for replying.

  1. You may be on to something. My recording was a stream from BBC Sounds. I’ll try something stand alone.
  2. I split the files on OB by selecting a section (movement of symphony), copying it and pasting into a new OB window and exporting that to desktop. Repeat with the other three movements.
  3. I dragged these into the ā€˜Burn’ software to make a CD

Pirate

The intrigue increases. :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:
Lots of stuff on BBC Sounds can be downloaded directly but it can be either MP3 or m4a, neither of which might suit you. If there is one, could you post a link to the symphony and let me delve into it a bit more, please?
Are you also in the UK then?
Mark B

I hope that I am writing in the right place.

As I said, I can’t cope with the technical stuff. However, I have done some experimenting:

Firstly I copied a small section of the symphony again from the BBC site, opened in Audacity and divided the result with ā€˜labels’. Result: Hiss.

Next I went to the same radio programme, only a week later, and recorded and split as before. Result: no hiss.

All the recordings, splittings and exportings were done in exactly the same way, with no adjustments to the settings on AudioHijack or Audacity.

It is all a mystery! Thanks to those who tried to help. I think I’ll leave it there.

Pirate

1 Like