One piece left out -- and you're doing the whole thing on one computer -- or you were until that turned out to be unworkable.We're a 2-man podcasting team and we call our guests on Skype
I don't know anybody doing a complex podcast like this, and apparently, nobody else does either. Everybody points to "people do this all the time." Who? Exactly? Whose podcast are we replicating?
I think any one of us can whip together a nice multi-point and multi-voice podcast, but we won't be doing it on one computer. Computers have exactly two sound channels, In and Out, and Skype takes both of them. Pamela "makes" more sound channels in system memory and that's how they record both sides of the conversation. Total Recorder does that, too.
Note that the computer is full -- overfull, really -- and we haven't dealt with talent microphones, headphones, and Audacity yet.
I asked you for the parts that Radio Shack supplied to allow you to plug your computer headphones into your mixer. I've never seen this offered as a commercial product and apparently, it's not. I have personally with these hands built all the stuff you need to do that. Into the XLR mixer connection, too -- a proper connection, because we needed that to work for one of our company systems. I can tell you specifically how to do it and which tools to buy. Do you know how to solder? Do you have an electric drill?
I've never seen any of this stuff available as commercial products.
I know how the grownups do this, I worked for a US television network, but it wasn't cheap and it took four people not counting the talent.
Have you looked at commercial "Podcast Products?" I've seen people offering packages that do the whole thing.
You can connect two USB microphones to some computers using "Aggregation." That's an engineering curiosity and not intended for production. You can't control the volumes and the two systems gradually drift out of lip sync.
Koz