Hide Extension

chen lung · Post by **chen lung** » Thu Jan 13, 2011 9:57 am

I've noticed on Preview's (the program) Save As, there's a tick-able 'Hide Extension' box.

Could that be implemented when saving/exporting in Audacity

?

Post by **steve** » Thu Jan 13, 2011 5:11 pm

Why do you want to hide extensions?

chen lung · Post by **chen lung** » Thu Jan 13, 2011 5:39 pm

steve wrote:Why do you want to hide extensions?

Why wouldn't I

?

Post by **steve** » Thu Jan 13, 2011 6:37 pm

What if you're Exporting a file with the name "myfile.wav" and you already have a file in the same location called "myfile.mp3"

Many Windows users write to the forum about being able to open a WAV or an MP3 file, when in fact it is not a WAV or an MP3, but they don't know that it isn't because Windows hides the extension by default. If I had a $ for every time that problem had happened I could jump into my private helicopter and fly over to chat to you about it in person

Now your turn - why would you like that option?

chen lung · Post by **chen lung** » Thu Jan 13, 2011 7:42 pm

I'm not sure what the problem with it is

.

The files would exist together no problem, as long as the extension is different. I'm using a Mac anyway (but I do have a PC too - not sure how it would be there, probably fine I think).

Post by **steve** » Thu Jan 13, 2011 8:03 pm

chen lung wrote:The files would exist together no problem, as long as the extension is different.

How would you know if the extensions are different if you have hidden the extensions?

You've still not said what the benefit is of hiding the extensions.

chen lung · Post by **chen lung** » Thu Jan 13, 2011 9:51 pm

steve wrote:
chen lung wrote:The files would exist together no problem, as long as the extension is different.
How would you know if the extensions are different if you have hidden the extensions?

You've still not said what the benefit is of hiding the extensions.

Would there not be a few indications - the file icon, hover over it for info, or in its properties?

It's just tidier looking. In windows, there's no risk of accidentally changing the extension if you are only changing the name (because it's hidden in system settings).

Post by **billw58** » Fri Jan 14, 2011 12:07 am

For all you non-Mac users, the option to "hide extension" is a standard feature in most file-save dialogs on Mac. The user has the option. I prefer to show extensions, others perfer to hide them. The question is why this is not implemented in Audacity for Mac. The answer probably lies in the cross-platform nature of Audacity, or the fact that no-one has noticed the lack of this feature and requested the developers to add it.

-- Bill

Post by **bgravato** » Fri Jan 14, 2011 5:30 am

I don't miss that option at all... as I don't miss wearing shoes with high heels, though some ppl might do...
I think this should be in the Adding Features forum.

Post by **steve** » Fri Jan 14, 2011 12:07 pm

Topic moved.

billw58 wrote:the option to "hide extension" is a standard feature in most file-save dialogs on Mac.

I note that you say "most" and not "all".
I expect that such an option would produce more user problems, so I'm -1 for this proposed feature.

Audacity Forum

Hide Extension

Hide Extension

Re: Hide Extension

Re: Hide Extension

Re: Hide Extension

Re: Hide Extension

Re: Hide Extension

Re: Hide Extension

Re: Hide Extension

Re: Hide Extension

Re: Hide Extension