Page 2 of 2

Re: Recording automotive exhaust sounds?

Posted: Mon Dec 24, 2012 6:25 pm
by Trebor
E4ODnut wrote:... I'd like to try recording under actual driving conditions so I'll be limited to having the mic on a short boom probably within no more than a metre of the tail pipe.
Contact microphones are used to record noise made by engine components, which are attached to the component (in "contact").
The sound recorded by a contact microphone could localise the sound made by one component, it would sound like you were using a mechanic's stethoscope, so not how it sounds normally to your unaided ear.

Re: Recording automotive exhaust sounds?

Posted: Mon Dec 24, 2012 9:39 pm
by kozikowski
...to me, the sound of a healthy engine, almost any engine, is as good as the finest of symphonies.
And a in any live performance, some if it is felt rather than heard. That doesn't connect until you try to record it.
It is a dual pattern condenser USB
Whose make and model is?
Omni because of the better low frequency response.
Omni or whatever is natural for your microphone is always going to sound better than any of the manufactured patterns. Cardioid patterns have two ratings, what does it sound like straight on and what does it sound like from the back. Everything's a balancing act. If you're doing all this outside, then you don't have to worry so much about echoes. Stay away from large buildings.
Then there is the matter of positioning the mic.
Plug good quality headphones in your computer and listen while you wave the microphones around (Edit > Preferences > Recording > Playthrough). You may have troubles not obvious. Microphones pick up reflections from the ground. Just starting the microphone on the ground and slowing lifting it up can be a revelation. When you see recordings in a studio, the microphone is generally three times closer to the performer than any large flat surface. Drums can mess that up, but those can be tuned so they sound good, not necessarily accurate. This is one place where directional microphones can be valuable.
it would be ideal if I could record in stereo
I wouldn't do it any other way. If you were on a Mac, there are ways to record two USB microphones, On a PC, you have the option of using two computers and two USB microphones. They don't have to be identical, but that's best.

Go out at the beginning and yell "MARKER" and clap your hands. You can use the hand clap to match up the two recordings later, one left and one right.

See what you talked yourself into?

Koz

Re: Recording automotive exhaust sounds?

Posted: Mon Dec 24, 2012 9:41 pm
by kozikowski
One other item. Vocal Microphones almost always have a low frequency droop and should be avoided in this case. Koz

Re: Recording automotive exhaust sounds?

Posted: Mon Dec 24, 2012 11:34 pm
by E4ODnut
Hi Koz,
The microphone is made by Samson and the model is "Go Mic".

It does have an output jack on it for head phones so I'll try that and see if positioning makes much of a difference. I'll probably have limited options in that regard though.

I made a few more test recordings with the 3 different settings and the recording volume turned right down. The Cardiroid with 10 db pad didn't cause any clipping but it seemed like the sound quality wasn't quite as good as the other two. Straight Card was pretty good but it had a few clips, didn't seem to notice it on a WAV playback though. The Omni had even more clips, but it seemed to sound a bit better and the clips didn't seem to cause any distortion. It was a tough call between Card and Omni though. It's interesting that I'm still getting clips with minimum record volume when I punch the throttle. I may be forced to use Card +10 to avoid them.

As far as editing is concerned, would it be best to avoid it completely if I can, to get the best reproduction?