fory
November 9, 2023, 8:36pm
1
Got the latest 3.4.1 installed. When I try to save(export) to mp3, the pop-up GUI defaults to “monoral” even “stereo” was chosen previously. I’m using Ubuntu 22.04
Testing on W10 with 3.4.1 (and the Beta test for 3.4.2 and the alpha test for 3.5.0)
I cannot reproduce this - stereo is properly offered as the default if I have stereo audio tracks -
I only get mono if I only have mono tracks in the project.
Peter
jademan
November 10, 2023, 1:33pm
3
This may be a function of whether or not your project is mono or stereo. I can reproduce this when saving a mono project, but NOT when saving a stereo project.
fory
November 10, 2023, 10:21pm
4
To reproduce, Timer Recording → Automatic export → Chose MP3
OOH so it does.
I think this is a bug - if you have your Audio Setup set to record in Stereo then I think this should default to stereo.
And this looks like a regression - a quick test shows that 3.0.0 did not do this.
I will log this as a bug on Muse’s GitHub later.
@fory good catch, thanks for the report
Peter
Logged as:
Timer Record automatic export defaults to mono when project is set to record in stereo #5580
opened 11:19AM - 11 Nov 23 UTC
bug
regression
recording
import-export
### Bug description
Timer Record automatic export defaults to mono when project… even if the user has their project set to record in stereo, which is the Audacity default setting.
This is a regression on 3.3.3 introduced in 3.4.0
### Steps to reproduce
1. in Audio Setup ensure Audacity is set to stereo
2. Transport > Recording > Timer record
3. click in the **Enable Automatic Export** box
4. click on the Automatic Export **Select** button
5. Observe: the export is set to default to mono
### Expected behavior
When the project is set to 2-channel stereo then the default Automatic Export in Timer Record should be stereo
When the project is set to 1-channel mono then the default Automatic Export in Timer Record should be mono
### Actual behavior

### Audacity Version
3.4.1 and 3.4.2 latest Beta
### Operating system
Windows 10 - but assume all OS
### Additional context
Originally reported on the Forum:
https://forum.audacityteam.org/t/save-to-mp3-defaults-monoral/89484
Peter.