recording of piano on cassette-quality

Wondering if anyone has any suggestions to someone new to Audacity and doesn’t know what settings to change. We have an audio cassette with recordings of a voice and then pianist, but the piano doesn’t come through in the recording after trying to transfer it via audacity. Have the cassette player connected via usb type c cable, and headphones plugged into cassette player can hear piano just fine. But it won’t play or come through in Audacity. What settings should I adjust? Thank you for your help

The voice from the tape is coming through OK?

[u]Windows “Enhancements”[/u] can foul-up the sound in strange ways and that’s the only thing I can think of…

Yes the audio is coming through just fine. Thank you, DVDdoug, for the suggestion - will look into that setting and see if it helps.