copying turntable record to digital, Is recording only one channel to both channels

Using Windows 10 Audacity 3.1.3 When copying using settings of MME, USB Audio, 2 (stereo) recording channel. Going through USB Phono Plus, the Monitoring bars L and R are identical. When listening to the record directly, there are definitely differences in the left and right recording. When listening to the Recording only one channel is there. I seem to totally missing the opposite channel. What do I need to do so it separates the L & R in the Audacity Recording and picks up each channel separately?

Make sure Windows is also [u]set for stereo[/u].