All (?) export formats distorted

I’ve used Audacity for years to record music from old LPs and export to WAV.
The current version of the export function appears to increase the output amplitude a lot, resulting in severe distortion, presumably due to clipping. This is true for WAV, MP3, FLAC, Ogg Vorbis, and I’m guessing for all other output formats. How can I force Audacity to not fool with the amplutude when exporting?

There is a volume slider to the left of the waveform. By default it should be centered at 0dB for no change.

Thanks! Somehow mine was set to +36 dB